Insurance Fraud Does Affect You - fraud

Insurance Fraud Does Affect You


Erie Mutual Insurance News, Insurance Tips Advice

Insurance fraud happens daily. You may think this only occurs in the large cities and has no bearing on any small town insurance company or your own policy, but you would be wrong. The insurance premium you pay every renewal is impacted by the fraudulent behavior of others, it is far more significant than most drivers or homeowners are ever aware.

When you hear the term insurance fraud, what do you think of? We would not be surprised if you probably pictured some large well thought out scam which has been orchestrated by a group of thugs ripping off the multi-million dollar insurance industry and large insurance stock companies of the world. You would be right, but only to a degree. Although some of the fraudulent insurance activity is fairly large scale and consists of a chain of criminals networking together for the sole purpose of ripping off your insurer, there is also a large portion which happens right in your neighborhood and may involve co-workers, friends or your local repair garage.

Insurance Fraud comes in many shapes and sizes, some more severe than others and some pretty mediocre by most standards but nonetheless still fraudulent.

Staged Auto Accidents

Dishonest drivers lure innocent motorists into an auto crash. Although damage may be minimal, crooks make claims looking for large settlements for fake injuries and excessive damage that they may inflict on the vehicle themselves.

Existing Damage Included

Drivers involved in an accident claim that existing damage was part of the accident in order to include it in the garage repair estimate for the insurer to assume the cost (also happens with property insurance claims for flooded basements when additional items are intentionally placed in the water to be damaged or wind damage when a roof of poor repair has only limited damage from the windstorm itself)

Repair Garage Escalated Repairs

The repair garage accepts a vehicle with minimal to mild damage and under the privacy of their shop create further damage to escalate the costs for repair that the insurance company will be required to pay them for parts and labour (also applicable to home repairs for professionals or contract work covered under an insurance claim)

False Information on an Application

Very common insurance fraud that many are guilty of and goes undetected for the most part. For Example, questions on an auto insurance application are intended to determine the appropriate insurance premium for each driver and automobile based on criteria regarding driving records and vehicle details. Guess how many people give a false answer to these questions hoping to lower their premium or deceive the insurer? (should we mention that people also provide false information on property or commercial applications for insurance too)

  • Purchase Price?
  • Automobile Use (including distance you commute one way)?
  • Estimated Annual Driving Distance?
  • Any existing Unrepaired Damage?
  • Has the vehicle been Modified/Customized?
  • Percentage of Vehicle Use by Each Driver?
  • Any other persons in the household or business licensed to drive?
  • Has any drivers license, vehicle permit etc, issued to the applicant or to any person in the household or business been suspended or cancelled in the last 6 years?
  • Has any insurance company cancelled automobile insurance for the applicant or any listed driver in the last 3 years?
  • Any previous accidents or insurance claims?
  • Any history of driving convictions for each driver?


As a community we are encouraged to report criminal activity, this includes anyone involved in, or an activity, which you believe to be insurance fraud. However, as a community in this day and age, we also tend to mind our own business and ignore what we see and hear going on around us. Like anything else in life, I guess the best advice is to choose your battles wisely. But realize that the consequences of these actions by others do affect you.

If you have witnessed or have information about insurance fraud or a potential crime, you can:

  1. File a report with local police and/or provincial or territorial Crime Stoppers organization.
  2. Make an anonymous call 24/7 to 1-877-IBC-TIPS (422-8477)
  3. Complete and submit an anonymous online tip form




Article Written by Darcy Johnson

Erie Mutual Insurance Manager – Sales, Marketing & Business Development

Read the Latest News

The basis of insurance is really quite simple and easy to understand, we complicate it by making assumptions and raising our expectations beyond reason.

October 17, 2018 4 Min Read

This is the perfect time to plan and begin projects around your home for the changing season and weather, especially outdoors. We are often reminded by insurance claims that better preparation and less procrastination may have saved both money and headaches for many homeowners.

October 3, 2018 3 Min Read

If you have ever built or had a contractor build, your own house then it should not surprise you that the final cost is never what you thought it was going to be at the start of the project. Why is that? 

September 25, 2018 5 Min Read

This field is required.
Invalid email format.
Some of the fields are not filled or invalid.
Form Template
Select a Form Template
Available fields in the selected template:
Templates Library
Loading, Please wait...
The Library cannot be open, please try it again later.