711 Main St. E. Dunnville, Ontario N1A 2W5

Follow Us Today


Print your In Case of Accident card here!

We have created this handy item for your to keep with your Insurance slips, print it online or ask for one from your Agent or CSR today

Erie Blog

  • Apr10Thu

    Your questions answered: Auto Insurance

    April 10, 2014
    Did you know that every insurance company license to write insurance in the Province of Ontario issues the same policy wordings?
  • Apr7Mon

    Four tips for buying a used car

    April 7, 2014
    There are a number reasons to buy a used car, and Ontario has one of the best used car markets in the world. Over one million used cars change hands in Ontario every year, according to the Ontario Ministry of Transportation, and somewhere in there may be the perfect car for you. Buying a used car can also be a scary process, however, especially if you are buying from an individual, and it's easy to get taken advantage of. With that in mind, we've put together a few tips to help our mutual insurance customers through the process.
  • Mar18Tue

    Outstanding 4-H aluma begins her career

    March 18, 2014
    Our Marketing Coordinator, Stephanie Huitema, was recently featured in a blog post for 4-H Ontario. She was interviewed on how 4-H has helped her become the person she is today & how it helped her start her career- here at Erie Mutual. We commend Stephanie on her achievements in 4-H and into the future!

Pay Your Policy Premium Here

visa mastercard

Now Available!! Pay your Erie Mutual Insurance Policy Premium online with your MasterCard or Visa.
Click Here

Sign Up for our e-Newsletter

Contact Your Agent or CSR

Should you need to contact your Erie Mutual Insurance Agent or chat with a Customer Service Representative, please call 1-800-263-6484 or click below to obtain an email address.


If you have been in an accident or have suffered a loss, and wish to report your claim, please click below.

Take our Claims Survey here

Request a Quote!

To request an auto, home or farm insurance quote, click on the word Forms in the red banner above call us at 1-800-263-6484.

Request a Quote Form

Helpful Links

Below are a few website links that will help you to navigate the Erie Mutual Insurance website, as well as connect to other government or Mutual Insurance information.

Customer Feedback Form
Classic & Custom Car Appraisals