711 Main St. E. Dunnville, Ontario N1A 2W5


We want to hear from you !! In the coming month you will receive a Customer Experience Survey which we are asking you to complete and return by July 1, 2015 (draw for $100 Gift Card). The Survey will ask you to rate various aspects of Erie Mutual - including Overall Customer Experience, Importance of Insurance Elements, Experience by Department, Preference of Communication and of course - Would you recommend Erie Mutual to a friend, family member or colleague ?  AND What can Erie Mutual do to improve your overall customer experience ? Completed Surveys can be returned by mail, fax, email (darcy@eriemutual.com) or drop off at the office. Thank you in advance for your participation !!

Erie Blog


Subscribe to Erie Mutual's e-newsletter

Office Hours

Monday-Friday: 8:30am-4:30pm
Saturday & Sunday: Closed

Pay your Policy Premium online

visa mastercard

Pay your Erie Mutual Insurance Policy Premium online with your MasterCard or Visa.
Click Here

Request a Quote!

To request an auto, home or farm insurance quote, fill out the form below or call us at 1-800-263-6484.
Request a Quote Form

Contact Your Agent or CSR

Should you need to contact your Erie Mutual Insurance Agent or chat with a Customer Service Representative, please call 1-800-263-6484 or click below to obtain an email address.

Social Media: 



If you have been in an accident or have suffered a loss, and wish to report your claim, please click below.
Take our Claims Survey here

Helpful Links

Below are a few website links that will help you to navigate the Erie Mutual Insurance website, as well as connect to other government or Mutual Insurance information.

Customer Feedback Form
Classic & Custom Car Appraisals
Ontario Mutuals Insurance Association