Why People Choose Erie Mutual

Erie Mutual offers affordable coverage for personal lines of insurance, including residential and auto, as well as commercial and farm. We understand that your insurance needs are ever changing. Erie Mutual offers a wide selection of packages and additional coverage to best fit your evolving lifestyle.

Service after the sale is always important to our team. We promise the best customer experience within the industry, proven results with over 93% retention level of loyal members.

Home - 04_Marr_Farm_187-e1550258529592

We offer peace of mind for your family livelihood in a farm insurance package that best fits your daily operations. We’ve insured farms since the day we started, we’re a neighbour you can trust.

Home - IMG_5796-copy-e1550258714125

Protect your business with an Erie Mutual commercial package. We offer the flexibility to bundle both your personal and business insurance, offering enhancements and increased limits customized to match your family needs and the growth of your business.

Home - 12_KarenRandy_047-e1550258089628

We know that your property is a major investment. Your home, rental properties, condos, or seasonal cottage all require various coverage ensuring proper protection, we’ve got you covered.

Home - 10_Darcy_131_crop

Auto insurance can be confusing and costly. Our team of professional insurance advisors will educate you in making an informed decision, and keep your family safe on the road.

Have questions or want a quote?

Contact one of our specialists today.

Or you can get started with a quote right away

Member Testimonials

"Excellent service, well knowledgeable! Very happy with the service, I will definitely recommend to friends and family"

Nick KatalinichErie Mutual Member (Fenwick)

"I've had the pleasure of dealing with Erie Mutual for nearly a year now and they've been wonderful at every step. Everyone I've spoken with has been friendly and helpful."

Myles CalvertTenpine Web Development

"The crew at Erie Mutual are always friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. We’ve been with them for 5+ years and always recommend the company to friends and family. We really enjoy working with a local company."

Natalie TchorzErie Mutual Member (Dunnville)

“Erie Mutual insures our home, automobiles, cottage and rental properties. They treat us like family with exceptional service by phone, email and even text. Regardless of what we need to be insured, I always know a call to Erie will find a solution and offer the right protection.”

Stacy StanleyErie Mutual Member (Dunnville)

“The true value of being with Erie Mutual is the people and service. I trust their professional advice for my insurance, I never worry if I have the proper coverage or the right amount of insurance”

Paul JacksonErie Mutual Member (Grand Bend)

"The best thing about this insurance company is the people, they take care of everything I need quick and easy!"

Carolyn WalshErie Mutual Member (Dunnville)

"Agents are excellent. They go past expectations to make sure you're well cared for!"

Brenda HeegErie Mutual Member (Dunnville)

"I have had the pleasure of doing with business with Adam Hegg. This is a top-shelf agent and took care of all my needs quickly and efficiently."

Steven RomboughErie Mutual Member (Fisherville)

“Erie Mutual is one of the greatest companies to deal with … Amazing customer service and prompt replies! Would never consider another company after being with them. Thanks Erie Mutual!”

Tina SipkensErie Mutual Member (Caledonia)

“Please accept my apology for not notifying you of insurance cancellation on my dad’s house. You were one of the most helpful during the difficult time in settling his affairs, the banks and government should follow your example of professionalism.”

Jim PothFamily of Erie Mutual Member (Port Colborne)

"Any Insurance company can tell you everything they can do for you. I have had claims through Erie Mutual. Customer Service, satisfaction and quick friendly settlement is of the utmost importance with your Insurance Company. That is what I received with Erie Mutual Everyone is always professional and helpful! Any question is just a phone call away."

Cindy Johnson-Murphy Erie Mutual Member (Dunnville)

Home - 12_KarenRandy_097-e1550259505323

How much coverage
is enough?

We will always provide you with the proper coverage and adequate limits to meet all your insurance needs.

Home - 02_KeenviewFarm_461-e1550259349875

Finding the right insurance
for you.

Your insurance needs change over time. Erie Mutual is a progressive insurance company based in the Hamilton Niagara region with a professional team to assess and match your needs with the best insurance available.

What makes
Erie Mutual different?

Home - wwu_response_times

Response Times

We recognize the value of your time and strive to always respond in a timely manner to all insurance needs, including insurance quotes for new business, servicing our members, or settling a claim.

Home - wwu_great_value

Great Value

We believe our members deserve more than the insurance coverage they’ve purchased. Objective insurance advice, comprehensive loss prevention, community investment and a commitment to the best member experience are part of the Erie value.

Home - wwu_respectful


We will have due regard for your insurance needs and wants. Our respect for every member is at the forefront of everything we do.

Home - wwu_extra_mile

Going the Extra Mile

Our Member Charter is a set of promises we make to you, our valued members. These promises ensure that each Erie Mutual member has a rewarding and long-lasting experience with Erie Mutual Insurance.

Home - wwu_professionalism


We believe professionalism is the culmination of appearance, actions, and decisions affecting our members. Our business relationship with you is built on being professional, we put heart into everything we do.

Home - wwu_exceeding_expectations

Exceeding Expectations

Exceeding member expectations is everyone’s job at Erie Mutual. This includes providing insurance service in an efficient and effective manner, and offering only the best member experience at every point of contact.

Check Out What Members Say About The Erie Mutual Value

Financial Reports Offer Full Transparency

Erie Mutual Insurance is proudly owned by our members holding an active Erie Mutual Insurance policy at this time. We offer full transparency to our members and make financial statements readily available for your review each year.

As a member, you are welcome to attend our Annual General Meeting each year to review the company’s financial statements and join us in electing directors as your company representatives.

We recognize that not everyone has time to attend our AGM, but it’s still important to provide easy access to our financial statements for viewing at your convenience.

Read the Latest News

As a mutual insurance provider of both farm and auto insurance (in addition to business and home), we often get questions related to farm vehicles including when and why to register a vehicle with a farm plate.

May 21, 2020 2 Min Read

Individually we all have different questions as we begin to emerge from lockdown: • How can I stay safe? • Are my clothes still in style? • How do I lose the pandemic 15? • Will there be a second wave? • What month is it? • What is that glowing hot ball in the sky?

May 20, 2020 3 Min Read

If 2020 has taught us anything so far, it is that most of us need to work on being better prepared in the event of a supply chain disruption. Power and communication are certainly high up there in terms of priorities but there is nothing more important for our survival than reliable food supply.

April 20, 2020 3 Min Read

Home - 2018-Business-Excellence-Award-Winner
This field is required.
Invalid email format.
Some of the fields are not filled or invalid.
Form Template
Select a Form Template
Available fields in the selected template:
Templates Library
Loading, Please wait...
The Library cannot be open, please try it again later.