Want a price for your home insurance in Haldimand or Niagara Ontario, but don't have the time to call?

Try our Online Home Insurance Estimator to receive a free estimate by email within minutes.

Zero cost, zero obligation! It's so easy!!

Available to residents of Haldimand and Niagara regions of Ontario Canada only.


Member Testimonials

  • "Erie Mutual Insurance is a wonderfully responsive insurance company committed to finding solutions for you. Dealing with an Erie Mutual agent is a revelation, especially after my experiences with impersonal large stock insurance companies! Erie Mutual is always there for you!"

    Graeme Bachiu

  • "I've had the pleasure of dealing with Erie Mutual and they've been wonderful at every step. Everyone I've spoken with has been friendly and helpful."

    Myles Calvert
    Tenpine Web Development

  • “Please accept my apology for not notifying you of insurance cancellation on my dad’s house. You were one of the most helpful during the difficult time in settling his affairs, the banks and government should follow your example of professionalism.”

    Jim Poth
    Family of Erie Mutual Member (Port Colborne)

  • "Excellent service, well knowledgeable! Very happy with the service, I will definitely recommend to friends and family"

    Nick Katalinich
    Erie Mutual Member (Fenwick)

  • "The crew at Erie Mutual are always friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. We’ve been with them for 5+ years and always recommend the company to friends and family. We really enjoy working with a local company."

    Natalie Tchorz
    Erie Mutual Member (Dunnville)

  • "Agents are excellent. They go past expectations to make sure you're well cared for!"

    Brenda Heeg
    Erie Mutual Member (Dunnville)

  • "I have had the pleasure of doing business with Erie Mutual. A top-shelf agent took care of all my needs quickly and efficiently."

    Steven Rombough
    Erie Mutual Member (Fisherville)

  • “Erie Mutual is one of the greatest companies to deal with …
    Amazing customer service and prompt replies! Would never consider another company after being with them. Thanks Erie Mutual!”

    Tina Sipkens
    Erie Mutual Member (Caledonia)

Have questions or want a quote?

Contact one of our specialists today.

Or you can get started with a quote right away

  • Business Insurance
  • Farm Insurance
  • Home Insurance
  • Auto Insurance
  • Business Insurance
    Business Insurance

    Business Insurance

    Protect your business with an Erie Mutual commercial package. We offer the flexibility to bundle both your personal and business insurance, offering enhancements and increased limits customized to match your family needs and the growth of your business.

    Start a Quote
  • Farm Insurance
    Farm Insurance

    Farm Insurance

    We offer peace of mind for your family livelihood in a farm insurance package that best fits your daily operations. We’ve insured farms since the day we started, we’re a neighbour you can trust.

    Start a Quote
  • Home Insurance
    Home Insurance

    Home Insurance

    We know that your property is a major investment. Your home, rental properties, condos, or seasonal cottage all require various coverage ensuring proper protection, we’ve got you covered.

    Start a Quote
  • Car Insurance
    Car Insurance

    Auto Insurance

    Auto insurance can be confusing and costly. Our team of professional insurance advisors will educate you in making an informed decision, and keep your family safe on the road.

    Start a Quote

What makes
Erie Mutual different?

Get a Quote

Discover the Mutual Difference

Financial Reports Offer
Full Transparency


View Report

Erie Mutual Insurance is proudly owned by our members holding an active Erie Mutual Insurance policy at this time. We offer full transparency to our members and make financial statements readily available for your review each year.

As a member, you are welcome to attend our Annual General Meeting each year to review the company’s financial statements and join us in electing directors as your company representatives.

We recognize that not everyone has time to attend our AGM, but it’s still important to provide easy access to our financial statements for viewing at your convenience.

Notice of the Erie Mutual Insurance 2024 AGM.

Read the Latest Articles

View All
Erie Mutual
Canadian insurance company